🛝 877M Debt. $30K Bonuses That Backfired. One Radical Staffing Fix

Welcome to Playground Post, a bi-weekly newsletter that keeps education innovators ahead of what's next.

This week's reality check: LAUSD faces an $877 million deficit and still has more staff than when it served 40% more students. Meanwhile, new research shows that paying top teachers $30K to transfer into struggling schools actually made them less effective. And one state is proposing a staffing model that ditches the one-teacher-per-classroom assumption entirely.

Have a bold idea for education? Put it to the test.

Tiny Fellowship is a 10-week program for builders in education who want to pilot their idea with real people.

You'll get coaching, a $5,000 stipend, and a proven method to test what works.

Applications are rolling, the sooner you apply, the better.

Want to learn more? Feel free to reach out to [email protected].

👉 Apply now

Data Gem

New York City's preliminary budget adds $543 million in new spending next school year to comply with the state's class size mandate, rising to nearly $943 million annually after that. The city needs 6,000 additional teachers at a cost of $602 million just to reach 80% compliance.

LAUSD Faces an $877 Million Deficit. It's Not Alone.

Los Angeles Unified School District will issue reduction-in-force notices to 657 central office employees on March 15. 

The board approved the move in a 4-3 vote.

The backdrop: a projected $877 million budget deficit for 2026-27 and enrollment declines that have persisted for 25 years.

Teachers aren't being laid off, but LAUSD is freezing hiring. The district needs 350 fewer elementary teachers and 400 fewer secondary teachers next year because there simply aren't enough students.

"We still have a workforce that is larger than when the district had 40% more students than we have today," said Superintendent Alberto Carvalho.

How did it get here? 

LAUSD hired over 6,000 employees using one-time federal COVID relief funds. Those funds are gone. And between 2024-25 and 2025-26, enrollment declines were double what was expected, partly driven by federal immigration enforcement.

LAUSD isn't an outlier. Broward County Public Schools in Florida expects to cut 1,000 employees this spring after losing $90.5 million to enrollment drops. Houston ISD laid off 160 uncertified teachers last fall and has proposed closing 12 schools.

Districts hired aggressively with temporary money, enrollment kept falling, and now they're stuck with structural deficits and staff levels that don't match student counts.

Carvalho warned the board that postponing action would only lead to deeper, more sudden cuts later. He also acknowledged enrollment won't improve next year.

For education innovators, the fiscal crunch is creating urgent demand for tools that help districts right-size operations without gutting programs. AI-powered administrative tools that reduce central office headcount might be of help here. 

The districts that survive this period will be the ones that learn to do more with fewer people.

$30K Bonuses Moved Top Teachers to Struggling Schools. It Backfired.

In 2009, the federal government launched a remarkable experiment. Highly effective teachers were offered $30,000 bonuses (adjusted for inflation) over two years to move into low-performing, high-poverty schools.

A 2013 study found it worked: test scores rose three to five percentile points among students taught by the transferring teachers.

But a group of researchers recently reexamined the data and found an intriguing twist. 

If those teachers had remained as effective as they were in their prior schools, the gains would have been even larger.

In reality, these top teachers dropped from the 85th percentile to the 66th percentile in their new schools. Great teachers became merely pretty good teachers.

What happened? Context changed dramatically. 

Teachers reported lower student motivation, more behavior problems, fewer resources, and less autonomy. The value-added measures accounted for differences in student population, so the drop wasn't inevitable. Teachers were simply less equipped for the challenges in their new environment.

"Teacher effectiveness is dynamic," says Matthew Kraft, a Brown University professor and coauthor of the new paper. "Teaching is a team sport."

Other research supports this. Teachers perform better when they find a school they like, when they work with effective peers, and when their school supports learning and collaboration. Experience with the same grade and student population matters too.

This adds nuance to a common assumption: that a child's individual teacher is the most important in-school factor. 

It's really the teacher plus the school environment that determines outcomes.

The original Talent Transfer Initiative still produced gains. But Kraft says it might have worked even better if the money went toward retaining top teachers already at those schools rather than transplanting outsiders.

The data suggests that school environment tools may matter as much as teacher quality tools. Products that help schools build stronger collaborative cultures, mentorship structures, and onboarding systems for new staff could have more impact than those focused solely on recruitment.

Pennsylvania Wants Teaching Teams

Teaching in Pennsylvania is at a breaking point, according to new research from PA Needs Teachers, a coalition led by the Teach Plus advocacy group and the National Center on Education and the Economy. 

Attrition is rising, turnover hits urban and rural districts hardest, and teachers report feeling burnt out and underprepared.

Their proposed solution: replace the traditional one-teacher-per-classroom model with something fundamentally different.

In practice, a group of 100 students would share a team of six educators guided by a lead teacher. That replaces the current model of four teachers each responsible for a separate classroom of 25 students with little feedback on their teaching.

New teachers would receive mentorship. 

Experienced teachers would get recognition and higher compensation. 

Paraprofessionals and tutors would focus on struggling students.

According to Teach Plus polling, 70% of educators nationwide said they would want their school to adopt this approach.

Philadelphia employs less than 20% of Pennsylvania's teachers but accounts for 30% of statewide attrition. New teachers with the least experience often get the most challenging assignments. Black and Hispanic students and those from low-income families are the least likely to get experienced, qualified teachers.

"We don't lose new teachers because they can't do the job. We lose them because we don't help them learn how and set them up for success," said Doylestown middle school teacher Jill Weller-Reilly, a report co-author.

Philly teacher and co-author Trey Smith put it another way: "Teachers are not all the same, so whatever system we design, we can't treat teachers like widgets or cogs in a big machine."

There are real hurdles. While most strategic staffing models are designed to be budget-neutral after the initial design phase, upfront costs are significant. Union buy-in is required. 

And Philadelphia, like other districts, has a history of innovative programs that fade away or lose funding.

Philadelphia Federation of Teachers President Arthur Steinberg signaled interest, telling that districts "must be more innovative with resource allocation to improve hiring, retention, and professional support."

Signal for education innovators: the 6-per-100 model needs scheduling software, real-time feedback loops, and role-differentiated professional development platforms. If even a fraction of districts adopt this approach, the market for tools that support collaborative teaching structures rather than individual classroom management could grow significantly.

⚡️More Quick Hits

This week in education:

• Screen time laws could sweep up edtech — Tennessee is banning devices in K-5, Missouri capping digital instruction at 45 minutes per day, and three more states are advancing legislation that could restrict edtech alongside social media

• Tennessee would let non-degreed private school teachers into public schools — Proposed bill grants emergency permits to private school teachers with 10+ years of experience but no bachelor's degree, signaling how desperate the teacher shortage has become

• Detroit special ed: 28 teacher vacancies, autism diagnoses rising — Michigan's statewide special education vacancy rate sits at nearly 5%, roughly double the overall teacher vacancy rate, while autism diagnoses climb from 25,000 to 27,000

• COVID relief funds gone, but more states commit to high-impact tutoring — Despite $120 billion in federal pandemic funds expiring, multiple states are funding tutoring with state dollars; Stanford research confirms substantial gains when delivered in small groups during the school day

To stay up-to-date on all things education innovation, visit us at playgroundpost.com.