🛝 Special Ed Disputes, Students Lack Belonging, Engagement Metrics Confuse Educators

Welcome to Playground Post, a bi-weekly newsletter that keeps education innovators ahead of what's next.

This week's reality check: Special education complaints are exploding while schools struggle with basic dispute resolution. Meanwhile, most students don't feel they belong at school, and educators can't agree on what engagement actually means.

💎 Data Gem

UNESCO's new survey of 400 higher education institutions finds 19% already have a formal AI policy and another 42% are developing one. 90% of respondents say they use AI in their professional work, yet 1 in 4 report encountering ethical issues.

Special Education Disputes Jump 22% as States Hit Capacity Limits

Written state complaints about special education violations rose 22% in 2023-24, reaching 9,927 cases - a 79% increase over the 10-year average of 5,537.

States are struggling to keep up, with complaint backlogs doubling from 3% to 6% in just one year. 

Only 81% of complaints were resolved within the required 60-day timeline, down from a 92% average.

Three states, California, Massachusetts, and Texas, accounted for 39% of all complaints nationally.

What's driving this surge? 

Marcie Lipsitt, a Michigan disability advocate, filed 12 state complaints in six months after years of filing almost none. 

Her reason: the federal Office for Civil Rights is "basically closed for business" after the Trump administration cut staff by half.

The staffing crisis extends beyond federal oversight. 

According to the Learning Policy Institute, 45 states reported special educator shortages, and nearly all states had 365,967 teachers who weren't fully certified for their positions.

But here's one bright spot: mediation still works. 

CADRE's analysis shows consistently high family-school agreement rates when both sides engage in voluntary mediation rather than formal hearings.

The market opportunity is there for companies that can help schools prevent disputes before they escalate. Think early intervention platforms, family communication tools, and compliance management systems that catch issues before they become formal complaints.

More Students Feel Like They Don't Belong at School

A new YouthTruth survey of over 200,000 students reveals that most U.S. students in grades 3-12 don't feel like they belong at school.

The data tells a troubling story. Elementary students report being bullied for appearance, learning style, and identity expression. Middle and high schoolers cite appearance, race, and gender expression as primary factors.

The consequences: bullied high schoolers are twice as likely to consider dropping out.

What actually reduces bullying? 

High school students seeing adults treat students from all backgrounds with respect. But there's a racial gap - Asian American and White students are significantly more likely to witness this respect compared to American Indian, African American, and Middle Eastern peers.

The research points to solutions beyond punishment: structured relationship-building, restorative practices, and creating cultures where "safety and belonging are non-negotiable."

Organizations focused on school climate and culture have a clear mandate here. Platforms that help schools build belonging, track relationship quality, and implement restorative practices could address a problem affecting millions of students daily.

Educators Can't Agree on What Student Engagement Actually Means

Over 90% of educators say student engagement is critical for understanding achievement, but they fundamentally disagree on how to measure it, according to Discovery Education's survey of 1,398 superintendents, teachers, parents, and students.

While superintendents and teachers agree on two indicators: asking thoughtful questions and contributing to classroom discussion - everything else varies wildly.

54% of superintendents see good test performance as engagement, but only 29% of teachers agree. 

Half of superintendents consider extra study time an engagement indicator, compared to just 22% of teachers.

99% of superintendents and 88% of principals say their district intentionally measures engagement, but only 60% of teachers agree. 

One in three teachers says the absence of a clear definition is a key obstacle.

Discovery Education's report highlights what CEO Brian Shaw calls "the need for a more standardized approach to measuring student engagement and connecting it to academic achievement."

The business case: schools need engagement measurement tools that work across different stakeholder perspectives and provide actionable data rather than just dashboards. Companies that can bridge the gap between what administrators want to track and what teachers can actually observe have a significant opportunity.

⚡️ More quick hits

This week in education:

Teacher-led AI ethics group — New Orleans engineering teacher partners with local tech group NOAI to create educator-driven model for responsible AI integration

Practitioner AI guidance — Opinion piece offers framework for moving past AI "approach-avoidance" paralysis toward classroom implementation

Virginia districts formalize AI policies — Lynchburg area schools emphasize responsible use guidelines while Campbell County trains staff on MagicSchool with spring student rollout planned

Small colleges pursue "free tuition" — Analysis of how private institutions with tight budgets structure last-dollar aid programs through donor partnerships and targeted offerings

🔎 Worth Checking Out

Monthly roundup of resources you might like:

• NCES District Revenue and Expenditure Data 2022-23 — Fresh national and state-level tables on district finances for FY2023, providing essential baseline data for market sizing and pricing strategies

• UK GenAI Literacy Study 2025 — Survey of 60k+ teens and 2,908 teachers shows 66.5% of students and 58% of teachers using AI, with strong calls for training on critical use

• 2025 PDK Poll Results — 57th annual survey shows strong public support for improving teacher pay, addressing shortages, limiting cell phone use, and majority opposition to eliminating the Education Department

• EdChoice August 2025 Polling — Half of Americans say K-12 is on wrong track, ~25% of parents report school switching, mixed views on eliminating Education Department

To stay up-to-date on all things education innovation, visit us at playgroundpost.com.